DON GIOVANNI
![]() |
Costume for Leporello |
to
ZEFFIRELLI
Zeffirelli is always in close liaison with the conductor. In the above sequence he and Georg Solti, Covent Garden's musical director, plan the opening scene of the opera.
There is a popular thought that opera singers habitually wear winged helmets, or at least gold lame. At the first rehearsal for Don Giovanni, the cast- eight soloists whose names mean House Full signs and hysteresis in the gallery-looked like nothing so much as a group of teachers gathered for a conference on comprehensive schools. They sat in a row before the footlights facing the stage, attention focused on one man, the director, Franco Zeffirelli.
It was 10.30 am. In the background a group of scene shifters decided to remove the backdrop (Oliver Messel's design for The Sleeping Beauty): somewhere a vacuum cleaner moaned in un-Mozartian tones: carpenters and electricians squatted in the wings, listening as Zeffirelli explained with quick gestures and unexpected passages of mime, his conception of Don Giovanni
His design for the opening scene was passed round, a sombre arrangement of pillars and heavy gates. The singers looked from it to the stage which had been built into a sloping ramp for this production, shallow but still tricky for high heels and active baritones ("No one will be able to call this a flat performance," commented Cesare Siepi after a slight skid).
Carefully Zeffirelli explained the exact effect he wanted for the opening of the opera. Geraint Evans and the conductor Georg Solti listened. "It is dark, there is gloom, terror and as you turn the light picks out your face." Evans nodded; in the wings, rehearsal pianist John Constable began the opening molto allegro and the rehearsal was under way.
That molto allegro was to be hammered out a number of times before singer and producer were equally happy about the staging.
Franco Zeffirelli is in his early thirties, a Florentine who began his career as a radio actor. He has appeared on the stage, and his first major stage designs were
for a Visconti production of A Streetcar Named Desire. He worked as assistant director on a series of Italian films (including Bellissima with Anna Magnani) and made his initial impact in opera at La Scala, Milan, in 1952.
This background of the theatre in all its aspects makes him unique among today's opera producers. His productions invariably attempt to be faithful to the composer's intentions and also to the period in which the work was written. His ability to make the most farfetched operatic conventions dramatically valid was seen in his handling of the mad scene in Lacia; the success of his realistic approach, in which every detail of the visual aspect of a production is essential to the ultimate effect, was demonstrated in his Romes & Juliet at the Old Vic.
Slightly built and with immense charm, Zeffirelli on stage never seems to stop moving or talking and often appears to be talking Italian and English at the same time. His enthusiasm bubbles over into active participation. He showed the Donna Anna (Gré Brouwenstijn, who later had to withdraw from the cast and has been replaced by Leyla Gencer how to make her first entry, clinging on to Don Giovanni and in negligée ("miles of silk and lace"). He immediately assumed the urgent sensuality of the role and though Miss Brouwenstijn was singing as she watched, he too sang her line. With a firm hand on the tempo Georg Solti joined in and for a vivid half-minute that particular moment in the opera crystallized.
Don Giovanni is a soloist opera, but the Act One finale requires chorus, ballet and extras. Tackling this episode, Zeffirelli gives a pretty good demonstration of how to do several things at once, while ensuring that everything fits into the pattern required.
His concern for the drama and the detail of action does at mean that Zeffirelli minimises the musical side. In fact, every move, action, gesture complements or reflects the music. "Only one or two tricks in each aria," he told the singers, and if an idea occurs that might harm the music (he wanted Donna Anna to scream at one point) the conductor is consulted.
In private life Franco Zeffirelli drives fast ears and collects antiques. At work this love of high-speed action and reverse for beauty combine to produce operatic performances that are usually collectors' items.

These are only first brief impressions which will be expanded next month, when we will publish a long and detailed review of this important new production together with photographs. After the many disappointments of the season, it was a pleasure to experience a performance in which the stage picture and production were in accord with the musical conception, even if one did not agree with this conception (I did), which stressed the drama almost at the expense of the giocoso.
Some people found Franco Zeffirelli's production fussy, but only at one or two points, at the most, did it get in the way of the music-and then only slightly; others complained about the waits between scenes despite the use of a front curtain-but how lovely to see solid, real scenery, in the grand manner. This seemed to me how Don Giovanni should look in a large opera house-rich, sumptuous, sensuous. Georg Solti's Mozart, likewise, may not be to all tastes, but again I liked his conception, which was serious, dramatic, and tense. And as usual the orchestra played extremely well for him.
Leyla Gencer has not a big dramatic voice, but she is a sensitive musician and sang Anna rather in the manner that one imagines Callas might sing the part: 'Non mi dir' was beautifully done. Sena Jurinac, indisposed, was still an Elvira to reckon with; and Mirella Freni's Zerlina was irresistible. Cesare Siepi's young-looking Don was all quicksilver and charm not quite demoniac enough perhaps, but extremely well sung. Geraint Evans's Leporello was keyed in a lower pitch than usual, but this was in accord with the Zeffirelli-Solti approach. Richard Lewis, ever the stylist, was a fine Ottavio; Robert Savoie an excellent Masetto; and David Ward completely magnificent in the closing scene as the Commendatore. H.D.R.
Artists Appearing 1960 – 1962
* Mariella Angioletti
Heather Begg
Teresa Berganza
Ursula Böse
Gré Brouwenstijn
*Biserka Cvejic
*Mary Costa
*Régine Crespin
Gloria Davy
*Anny Delorie
*Joan Edwards
Victoria Elliott
*Mirella Freni
*Rena Garazioti
*Catherine Gayer
*Leyla Gencer
Rita Gorr
*Maureen Guy
*Heather Harper
Margaret Harshaw
Marga Höffgen
Grace Hoffman
*Ann Hood
Sena Jurinac
*Raina Kabaiwanska
Iris Kells
Gloria Lane
Edith Lang
Adèle Leigh
*Marguarita Lilova
*Laura Londi
*Marijke van der Lugt
*Julia Malyon
Elsie Morison
*Margaret Neville
Birgit Nilsson
*Norma Procter
Judith Pierce
Roberta Peters
Rosina Raisbeck
Regina Resnik
*Marion Roberts
*Irene Salemka
Monica Sinclair
*Teresa Stratas
Joan Sutherland
Marjorie Thomas
Herta Töpper
*Ivana Tosini
*Gabriella Tucci
*Anita Välkki
*Galina Vishnevskaya
Claire Watson
Virginia Zeani
Luigi Alva
*Ettore Bastianini
*Emile Belcourt
*Ernst Blanc
*Grayston Burgess
*Enrico Campi
Boris Christoff
*Renato Cioni
Charles Craig
Murray Dickie
*Agostino Lazzari
Richard Lewis
William McAlpine
*Robert Massard
*Pietro Menci
James Milligan
Mario del Monaco
Nikola Nikolov
*Russell Oberlin
*Luigi Ottolini
Peter Pears
Ronald Dowd
Geraint Evans
Gottlob Frick
*Peter Glossop
Tito Gobbi
*Richard Golding
*Nicolae Herlea
Richard Holm
Hans Hotter
*Ernst Kozub
*Walter Kreppel
Albert Lance
James Pease
Arturo Sergi
Cesare Siepi
*Thomas Stewart
*Gerhard Stolze
*Giuseppe Taddei
Hermann Uhde
Alain Vanzo
Jon Vickers
Wolfgang Windgassen
Alexander Young
Robert Thomas
John Shirley Quirk
*These artists making their
first appearance at Covent Garden.
London Opera Diary
As I have said in my Comment on page 224, I have little patience with those people who can only find fault with everything Franco Zeffirelli turns his hand to, and even less with those who think that it is wrong to
Photo: Don Giovanni (Cesare Siepi) dines in style, while Leporello (Geraint Evans) looks on
Granted, then, that there are other ways of doing Don Giovanni, and accepting that for Covent Garden the romantic approach as exemplified in this Zeffirelli-Solti production is possibly the best way to do it, let us proceed from there.
I think that few will deny that the series of stage pictures that were unfolded were amongst the most splendid ever seen on any opera stage, and the evocative lighting by Zeffirelli and William Bundy exhibited them and the richly bejewelled costumes to wonderful advantage. The Watteau- like set of the first Zerlina-Masetto scene, used again for the opera's closing moments, was madly out of period, but a delight to the eye none the less. It was possibly a mistake for the ballroom and banqueting room to be identical; the long rows of men in armour disappearing into the gloom seemed fitting for the supper scene, but not for the merry making at the end of the first act. Outstanding was the opening scene (used also for the second scene in Act 2), and especially the street scene with Elvira's inn.
In the general production there were two points where I would take Issue with Zeffirelli: the first occurred during the great quartet 'Non ti fidar, o misera' when one's attention was forced to wander from the four soloists to the group of villagers that Zeffirelli brought on to watch the proceedings for a few moments; the second was the rounding off the opera by having Zerlina and Masetto return to their friends in the Watteau-like setting. Presumably the Don's palace vanished in the mists and clouds that swallowed up the Don? There were one or two places as well where Zeffirelli's master-touch failed-notably the cemetery scene. where the Statue seemed too far back and awkwardly placed to make its full effect; and in the Act 1 finale, from Zerlina's scream to the end. which was a general muddle.
There were, on the other hand, countless little touches in the individual characterizations that were a joy to see. One loved the way the Don took off his hat and cast it to the ground before every possible conquest; one approved of the way Elvira was made into a sensuous womanly figure, and, for the first time, her many entrances did not raise a smile or laugh; Leporello was seen as a vital figure in the Don's household, more a companion than a servant ; and so one could go on.
Musically Mr Solti's reading was at one with the producer. His was a frankly romantic and dramatic approach-and yet the exquisite details and charm were there too. One recalls the seduction in the orchestra as well as in Siepi's voice in 'La ci darem'; the wonderful string playing in 'Ah! fuggi il traditore'; the beautifully shaped postludes to 'Dalla sua pace', and 'vedrai carino' (and incidentally how clever Zeffirelli was here. to fill up those closing moments with action, thus preventing premature applause and so letting us hear those exquisite 20 bars); the twining larghetto of the rondo to 'Non mi dir-all these I can still hear with my inner ear. But do let us have a consistent policy with regard to appogiaturas!
I have already commented on Siepi's Don, a role he has made his own. and one in which he succeeds in lightening his bass voice most success- fully. In fact, one did not mind having a bass Don and bass-baritone Leporello on this occasion. Geraint Evans's mastery of the stage increases at every performance, and it must be really gratifying for him to receive an increasing number of invitations to sing abroad. A moment I will never forget occurred in the 'Catalogue' aria, when he hastily opened the 'picciol libro' to make quite sure that it really was 'mille e tre' in Spain!
Leyla Gencer's exquisite singing of 'Non mi dir' was a highlight of both performances. Perhaps she has not the ideal voice of steel for Anna, and so 'Or sai chi l'onore' fell a little flat. But she is a fine artist, with a most beautiful middle register, and she can produce the most ravishing pianissimos. Mirella Freni's Zerlina was as perfect an interpretation in every respect as one could wish for. One sees boundless possibilities for the future of this most gifted artist. Sena Jurinac's Elvira is an old friend; unfortunately, she was ill on the first night and had to omit 'Mi tradi'- by the broadcast performance she was back in voice, and sang it as only she can. Claire Watson, the Elvira of the last three performances,
DON GIOVANNI
Opera in two acts by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart; words by Lorenzo Da Ponte. Producer Franco Zeffirelli; scenery and costumes by Franco Zeffirelli; lighting by Franco Zeffirelli and William Bundy. First performance of new production at the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, 9 February 1962
Leporello Geraint Evans
Conductor: Georg Solti
is an accomplished and lovely artist. However, Elvira is not her part temperamentally-she would be a good Anna one feels.
Richard Lewis still sings Italian strangely, but Mozart extremely well. Both the Ottavio arias were well done, the 'Dalla sua pace' being well- nigh perfect. André Turp, with his warmer Italianate method of singing. made Ottavio into a more vital figure than had Mr Lewis, and for a first attempt at Mozart this promised well. He is not yet technically accomplished enough to cope with the hazards of 'Il mio tesoro', and he sounded rather short of breath. Robert Savoie made much of Masetto, and revealed a fine, dark-grained baritone. For David Ward's Commendatore no praise is too high. He looked and sounded magnificent. And I have rarely heard such a stream of solid tone from any bass on the Covent Garden stage as he produced in the supper scene.
Finally, a word for the future. This is too fine an achievement to leave lying fallow even for a season. It must obviously have needed many months of planning to have assembled the cast for these performances, and it might well be a long time before we got them all together again. But suitable alternatives do exist, and one hopes that another series of Don Giovanni performances will form part of the 1962-3 season. H.D.R.
Don Giovanni
At Covent Garden Franco Zeffirelli staged a sumptuous
Don Giovanni [Feb 9] in which the dominant impression was left by soaring
arches, tremendous perspectives, larger-than-life suits of armour, Watteauesque
parks and post-Impressionist townscapes, romantic gloom, and heavy crusted
costumes from Velasquez. It was not a swift- moving drama played out in music
and intelligible words, but a Grand Opera House entertainment distinguished by
lavish spectacle, spacious music, and impassioned star performances. On the
first night the action was held up by long waits while tons of scenery were
shifted into place (this was improved later but at the cost of hearing the
stage- hands at work behind the drop-curtain).
Don Giovanni > Opera News > The Met Opera Guild
The Practice > Opera News > The Met Opera Guild
Don Giovanni > Opera News > The Met Opera Guild
Recording Excerpts [1962.02.19]
DEATH OF BRUNO WALTER
FROM CD BOOKLET
![]() |
FROM CD BOOKLET