With Governor Ronald Regan, Nancy Reagan and Grace Bumbry
With Lotfi Mansouri, Stage Director in her dressing room
RENO GAZETTE
1967.05.19
THE TIMES
1967.08.09
The Opera Cast
Set They will be working with Welsh baritone Geraint Evans
(from London), American soprano Jane Marsh (From New York), American soprano
Jeanette Scovotti (from Germany), British tenor Stuart Burrows" (from
London), and American bass Thomas O'Leary (from Germany) and the rest of the
east. Two California artists of international repute, Jess Thomas (from
Bayreuth) an Irene Dalis. Opera stars from all parts of the globe are in
rehearsal for the 1967 San Francisco Opera which opens its ten - week season on
September 19. On hand to rehearse the opening night's "La Gioconda'' are Turkish soprano
Leyla Gencer (flying from Verona),
American mezzo Grace Bumbry (from Salzburg via Newport) Canadian contralto
Maureen Forrester (from Pennsylvania), and Italian tenor Renato Gioni (from
Milan). These artists will be having their first musical run - throughs with
the dynamic young Italian conductor Giuseppe Patane (from Germany) and staging
with Lotfi Mansouri (Geneva via Santa Fe) The German team of Horst Stein and
Paul Hager, conductor and stage director, respectively, who teamed together for
last, season's successful new "Tannhauser," are together again for
the company's new tub Sack.
SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER
1967.08.09
SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER
1967.08.15
THE PENINSULA TIMES TRIBUNE
1967.08.16
THE TIMES
1967.08.17
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
1967.08.20
VALLEJO TIMES HERALD
1967.08.20
DAVIS ENTERPRISE
1967.08.22
THE JEWISH NEWS
1967.08.25
THE PRESS TRIBUNE
1967.08.27
REDWOOD CITY TRIBUNE
1967.08.31
OPERA MAGAZINE
1967 September
UNKNOWN NEWSPAPER
1967 September
SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER
1967.09.01
THE MODESTO BEE
1967.09.03
DAVIS ENTERPRISE
1967.09.18
SAN FRANCISCO GATE
2015.09.18
This column originally
appeared in The San Francisco Chronicle on Sept. 4, 1967
Les folies bourgeoise, Herb
Caen, 1967
The annual Hairdressers’ and Dressmakers’
Costume Ball, with incidental music by Amilcare
Ponchielli, opened Tuesday night at the Opera
House, and, except for occasional interruptions by a
traveling band of minstrels, the evening was pronounced a signal success — the
principal signal being a strangled, “Hey, bartender, where’s that drink I
ordered an hour ago?” As the beginning of the fall season it was the absolute
end, and the flower and glory of our metropolis was there in full drag, madly
playing the great game of Very San Francisco, the men done up to their false
teeth, the women with every false hair in place, the false smiles being worn
bravely from 5:30 p.m. till 3:30 a.m. If you get the idea that it was something
less than culture’s finest hour, you could be right. However, as couture’s
finest hour it was something else again. “An exotic and irrational
entertainment,” as Dr. Sam
Johnson, who wasn’t there, once put it.
The trouble with opera openings in this
town is that they start rather obscenely in broad daylight, providing the
unique spectacle of men wearing white tie, tails and sunglasses. Then there are
all these black limousines speeding down Van
Ness, as though to a gangster’s funeral (it’s a great
night for the Chauffeurs’ Union). I used the family Rolls-Royce, a
seven-passenger limousine boasting a TV set in the rear compartment (when I say
the family Rolls, I don’t mean my family’s. I mean Kjell Qvales’s family at British
Motors). As dear departed Lucius always maintained, there is
something special about a vintage Rolls. As we approached the carriage
entrance, mere Cadillacs sank to their knees. It was the first time I ever saw
a traffic cop uncover himself and tug his forelock.
En route to this twi-night doubleheader I
sat back in that smashing car, turned on “Garrison’s Gorillas,” and browsed
through Kobbe’s Complete Book of the Opera, which devotes seven full pages to
the evening’s bon-bon, Signor Ponchielli’s “La Gioconda.” Like most librettos,
this one makes no sense at all (“When he has gone, Gioconda, who anticipating
the fate that might befall the woman who has saved her mother, has been in
hiding in the palace, hastens to Laura and hands her a flask containing a
narcotic that will create the semblance of death” — and like that). Keeping one
eye on “Garrison’s Gorillas,” I riffled to the last page, anticipating that
Gioconda would stab herself in the end, and she does. Now that I knew that, I
could relax and enjoy the show.
Lord Chesterfield said the opera is “a
magic scene contrived to please the eyes and the ears at the expense of the
understanding.” Right again, Chesty. It is indeed a magical moment when the
lights dim in the great opera house and the golden curtain glows, every patch
showing. As you settle back, tails folded primly across your lap, the orchestra
plays the National Anthem and you struggle to your feet again for another
magical moment: tails caught in seat. This accounts for the half-crouched
position you may have noticed. At the end of the Anthem, half a dozen wags
hooted, “Play ball!” and everybody giggles. It is thus that the overture
begins, interfering only slightly with the conversations in the audience. The
curtain rises and there is Mme. Leyla
Gencer, the Turkish soprano who sings like — well, a Turk (I
expected “Dardanella” any minute). And there’s Renato
Cioni, who sings North Beach tenor, mainly from da t’roat,
wearing a neo Shriner’s outfit and Adler elevator booties (this is not one of Kurt
Herbert Adler’s sidelines, so far as is known.) Anyway,
the book was right, except that Mme. Gencer didn’t stab herself in the end. She
went for the ribs.
The between-the-acts activity was
considerable. Two guards were stationed at Gov. Reagan’s box, prompting a
Democratic lady to observe nastily, “Why all the fuss? There are plenty more
like him where HE came from.” The mezzanine bar, where people have been known
to claw each other to death for one lousy drink, has been refurbished. It now
has a soundproof ceiling, to keep the music from seeping through, and a longer
bar, placing the bartender farther away than ever. Surveying the glittering
scene, I observed “This is the grownups’ New Year’s Eve.” “Halloween,”
corrected Maryon
Davis Lewis, darkly eyeing a woman wearing more falls
than Niagara and false eyelashes that flies could use as a landing field. Joan
Hitchcock walked in with her heroic cleavage and Melvin
Belli. “They make a lovely trio, don’t they?” inquired Tony
Hail. Those cultured titans from the south, Norman and Buffy
Chandler, sat out the second act and well into the third,
rushing back to their box for “Dance of the Hours” (“Hello, fodda, hello
mudda,” as Allan
Sherman sings it). Anyway, it’s nice to know what the
culturati really dig.
Style note: Whereas the ladies all have to
have new gowns for the opera, it’s a source of pride among men to boast about
the age of their tails — a nice example of reverse snobbism. David
Dibble, for instance, wears his grandfather’s tails, made
circa 1911; they are positively green with age, turning the rest of us ditto
with envy. John
Rosekrans, Jr., was wearing his late father’s white
waistcoat (it was John Sr., at an opera opening, who once coined the classic
complaint about champagne: “You get full before you get tight.” As for my
tails, they date back to 1951 and only now are getting suitably frayed. Tucking
some between my legs, I fled the scene, reflecting that whereas Kurt Adler had
succeeded in reviving “La Gioconda” in four hours, revising this particular
audience would take considerably longer.
From Arthur
Bloomfield’s book The San Francisco Opera 1922 – 1978
(1978 Comstock Editions)
……. Francesca project stemmed
from the fact that Tebaldi was learning the role for Maggio Musicale in
Florance. When that the Festival dropped the work, she was less interested in
doing it for San Francisco. It was more feasible for Adler to go ahead
substitute soprano than a substitute opera – the production was already built
when the unwooable Tebaldi made her decision – so Leyla Gencer, a Turkish
soprano with Italian opera experience, was imported. She turned out to be an
exceptionally interesting if uneven artist. Her physical beauty at the time was
marked, her poise sure, her pianissimi exquisite, her voice in general, when
well-projected, remarkably warm in tone. Whether she made more or less of
Francesca than Tebaldi might have done is one of history’s little question marks. ……. The report continued with a statement
of the position of the San Francisco Opera, which was, not surprisingly, that
Madam Callas was fired, and that a complaint, furthermore, was being sent off
to the American Guild of Musical Artists. The fact that a recording of
Cherubini’s Medea was on the ailing Callas’ September schedule – sessions took
place from 12th to 19th – did not sit exactly well with
Adler and Miller. Nor the fact that she “rested up” by going to an early
September ball tossed for her in Venice by Elsa Maxwell. Callas had wired Adler
September 1 that he should have a sub on hand “in case”. Bul Callas’ logical follow-up,
in Adler’s estimation, would have been either come on schedule and try to
perform, or to cancel outright, and stay home. Most subscribers felt Adler and
Miller were to be commended for their uncompromising action, and after Leonie
Rysanek’s Lady Macbeth and Leyla Gencer’s Lucia – both highly successful –
Maria Callas was, if not forgotten, hardy missed. ……. Gencer’s Lucia was not of the pretty-pretty
pyrotechnical variety. Here was a warm spinto soprano who simply happened to
have coloratura flexibility as well. The riches of her voice which, like Callas’,
has a certain sonic sex appeal, helped produce an adult Lucia. Also, vivid
acting: she conveyed a real sense of derangement in the Mad Scene. All in all,
this was the most memorable portrayal offered in San Francisco by a sometimes-remarkable
artist. Her success in the part indicated that another reengagement was in order,
and she returned in 1958. Her other assignments were Violetta and Liu, the latter
only in Los Angeles. ……. Mezzo Irene Dalis
appeared first in one of her best roles, Eboli in Don Carlo. She swung into it
with a fiery regality and sang it warmly, winning friends who would welcome her
back in many seasons to come. She shared to honours in the first two
performances with Tozzi, whose limping, swaggering Philip certainly one of the
best all-around characterizations her offered through the years of personages
more interesting than the stock Ramfis and Zaccaria types. Frank Guarrera was a
vivid Rodrigo, Piero Miranda a so-so Don Carlo. No soprano has ever known
better than Leyla Gencer how to stand about looking noble, but her vocal projection
in the role of Elizabeth was spotty. …….
Opening Night
1967 brought a revival of Gioconda, not seen nineteen years. Adler had waited
until he had the whopping sort of cast that can make this over-climaxed irresistible
warhorse run. Up through the summer of ’67 there were problems, two of his choices
agreeing the job and then backing off. Crespin was to do her first Gioconda,
and she had coaching with Zinka Milanov in Yugoslavia on her agenda, but
indisposition made it impossible for her to learn the role in time, and Peter
Glossop defected from Barnaba for Fallstaff with Sarah Chadwell’s American
National Company which toured the U.S. in the wake of the prematurely hatched
Met National troupe. Crespin was ably enough replaced by Leyla Gencer, absent
for nearly a decade from San Francisco scene. For Barnaba there were the
parched tones of Chester Ludgin, a man-of-all-work baritone who was encountering
vocal problems especially inconvenient for such a draftable singer. With Patané
exceedingly crisp, cultivated man on the podium. Grace Bumbry an ideally
handsome, mellifluous Laura, Maureen Forrester (a rare figure on the operatic
stage) a plummy Cieca, and Cioni a pingy Enzo, this was, despite problems, a
Gioconda lineup not to be dismissed. Gencer’s dramatic handling of the title role
made one respect her artistic integrity even as one worried over instances of
vocal abandon. Espaccially after the opening night, a traditionally troublesome
time for voices, she achieved a fairly even effect, always using her voice,
according to her habit, as a piece of highly charged equipment. There have been
more brilliant-sounding sopranos of the Gioconda type, but none more
resourceful. Gioconda being sort o character whor turns up from everybody’s
woodwork, she tends to be more than a bit tiresome, but Gencer put you on her
side.
lstanbul'da
güzel bir yaz tatili geçirdikten sonra sonbaharda San Francisco'ya uçtum.
Havaalanında tiyatronun iki başoyuncusu beni karşıladı. Arabayla Stanford
Üniversitesi'ne gittik. Orası bir cennet. İspanyol, daha çok da Fas tarzı bir
mimari ... San taş yapılar, sütunlar, kemerler. Masmavi gök, pırıl pınl güneş,
her yanda en az yirmi metre boyunda palmiyeler, renk renk, biçim biçim
çiçekler. Bir de Ravenna'dan getirilen mozaiklerle döşeli Bizans tipi koca bir
kilise. Kiliseye giden yolun iki yanında sıralanan palmiyeler. Bir çevreme
baktım, bir de Pittsburgh'a ilk gittiğim günü düşündüm. Ne tezat ama!
Araba
kullanmadığm için kampüs ve tiyatroya yakın bir evde bana bir oda tuttular.
Bir doktorun evinin ikinci katında, ağaçlara bakan ferah bir oda Yine de beni
arabayla alıp işe götürüyorlar, işten sonra da eve bırakıyorlardı.
Kaliforniya’da araba kullanmıyorsanız, kötürümden farkınız olmaz.
Stanford
Tiyatrosu'nun 1967 sezonu açılış oyununu seçtim. Korkumdan iyi bildiğim bir
oyun seçmeyi tercih etmiş ve Carnegie'de öğrencilerle sahnelediğim Anouilh'in
Mağara oyununda karar kılmıştım. Başrollerden biri olan aşçıyı da ben
oynayacaktım. Bu kararım herkesi şaşırttı. Amerika'da rejisörler, bizdeki gibi
sahneye koydukları piyeslerde rol almazlar. Zaten yönetmenlerin çoğu oyuncu da
değildi. Yönetmenlik ve oyunculuk iki ayrı meslek dalıdır.
Sendikanın
kurallarına göre, günde sekiz saat prova yapıyorduk. Oyuncu kadrom iyiydi, ama
yine de provalarda hayli sıkıntı çektim. Öyle ki, kimi zaman eve gider,
sinirden kusardım.
O
güne kadar yalnızca Türk oyuncular ve Amerikalı öğrencilerle çalışmıştım.
Amerikalı profesyonel oyuncuların çalışma yöntemi bambaşkaydı. Türkiye'de
rejisör bir tür diktatör gibi hareket eder. Oysa Amerika'daki oyuncular,
istedikleri sonuca varana kadar bir sürü deneme yapmak istiyorlardı. Onlara
nasıl oynamaları gerektiğini söylediğiniz zaman da kızıyor, hırçınlaşıyorlardı.
Çoğu kez, "Ben sonunda sizin görüşlerinize varacağım; ama lütfen hangi yoldan
gideceğimi ben bulayım. Bana neyi nasıl yapacağımı söylemekten vazgeçip, ne
istediğinizi söyleyin, bunları kendim çalışayım" diye çıkışırlardı.
Üç
hafta boyunca tam anlamıyla canım çıktıktan, yüreğim ve bedenim yıprandıktan
sonra oyun açıldı. Çok şükür, San Francisco eleştirmenleri oyunu beğendiler.
Rejiyi, oyuncuları göklere çıkardılar. Ben de rahat bir soluk aldım. Piyes
beğenilmeseydi, çok zor bir duruma düşecektim. Herkes, "Bu Türk yönetmende
iş yok, Hollandalı çok daha iyiydi" diye verip veriştirecekti. Provalarda
bana içerlemiş olan oyuncular, eleştirmenlerin oyunu beğenmesine adeta
üzüldüler. Ama başarı baldan tatlıdır. Sonunda bana karşı tutumları değişti.
O
sırada Leyla Gencer, San Francisco Operası'nda Norma’yı oynuyordu. [Not: Gencer 1967 yılında SF Operasında La Gioconda ile
açılışı gerçekleştirdi. Sanırım burada operalar karışmış] Gidip
seyretmeyi çok istiyordum, ama nasıl gidecektim? Ehliyetim yoktu, ama
direksiyon dersi almaya başlamıştım. Ev sahibim olan doktora, "Operaya iki
bilet alsam, beni götürür müsünüz?" diye sordum. Doktor teklifimi kabul
etti ve "Operadan sonra da ben sizi yemeğe davet ediyorum" dedi. Onun
arabasıyla operaya gittik. Leyla Gencer her zamanki gibi harikaydı. Oyundan
sonra makyaj odasına gittim, sarılıp öperek kutladım. İçimden, "Ahh, şimdi
çarşaflı ecdadımız bizi görse" diyordum. Bir Türk kadım San Francisco
Operası'nda başrol oynuyor; bir diğeri Stanford Tiyatrosu'nda başarılı bir
piyes sahneye koyuyordu. İlk Müslüman Türk kadın oyuncu Afife Hanım 1919' da
sahneye çıktığı zaman, polis tiyatroyu basmıştı. Atatürk'ün sayesinde,
kadınlarımız az zamanda ne çok şey başardı.